The Fraud of Bukhari’s ‘Fourth Criterion’

Bukhari’s famed “proven meeting” criterion is often seen as a hallmark of hadith authenticity. Yet it relies on unverifiable assumptions, logical fallacies, and easily fabricated claims; offering the illusion of rigor while failing to genuinely prove transmission ever occurred.

0 Comments

Quran-Centrism Does NOT Work

Quran-centrism creates an impossible theological choice: either falsely attribute unverified statements to the Prophet Muhammad (a serious religious offense), or admit you're just collecting inspirational quotes while calling them "hadith." Both options undermine the methodology's credibility and intellectual honesty.

0 Comments

Ibn Taymiyah’s Views on Arab Superiority

Ibn Taymiyah's claims of inherent Arab racial superiority directly contradict the Quran's clear emphasis on equality based on righteousness alone. This contradiction challenges Muslims to prioritize Quranic principles over even respected scholarly opinions that reflect historical biases rather than divine guidance.

0 Comments

The Origin of Islamic Apostasy: The Slave of Ibn Abbas

‘Ikrimah’s Kharijite leanings influenced his transmission of hadiths advocating immediate execution for apostates, shaping later Islamic jurisprudence. Imam Malik, however, adopted a more lenient stance based on a weakly transmitted narration from Umar, raising doubts about its authenticity and historical accuracy.

1 Comment