Unveiling The
History of Hadith

Featured · BLOG

The Quranic Epistemology of Verification (Q. 49:6)

This article explores Quranic Epistemology and its principle of verification, contrasting the Quran’s evidence-based method of truth with...

Read Mar 2026

BLOG

Most Popular Hadith Website (Sunnah.com) Caught Manipulating Hadith

The "green Arabia hadith" (Sahih Muslim 157b) was likely fabricated in the 8th century under Umayyad rule to...

Read Feb 2026

BLOG

More on: The Fabricated ‘Baghdad’ Hadith Prophecy

A widely-cited hadith claiming to predict the Mongol invasion of Baghdad was actually fabricated by Basran narrator Sa'id...

Read Nov 2025

BLOG

The Day They Seated the Prophet Besides God (literally)

A shocking early Sunni tafsīr claimed the Prophet Muhammad would sit beside God on His Throne. Defended by...

Read Oct 2025

BLOG

Sunnis Have Disbelieved in 5:3 of The Quran.

If God declared the religion complete in 5:3, later inventions like hadith compilations, rijāl criticism, naskh, tafsīr, madhhabs,...

Read Sep 2025

BLOG

How the Legal Islamic Class Invented Their Own Divine Reward

The “Judge’s Reward” hadith appears only after Malik’s death, suggesting late fabrication. Its Medinan transmitters were judges who...

Read Sep 2025

BLOG

The Sunni-Quranic Abrogation Dilemma

This article critiques the doctrine of naskh (abrogation) in Sunni Islam, highlighting contradictory lists of abrogated verses, exposing...

Read Sep 2025

BLOG

Wittgenstein’s ‘Beetle’ in the Isnād

This blog applies Wittgenstein’s “beetle in the box” critique to hadith science, exposing how assessments of honesty, memory,...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

Hume’s Problem of Induction vs. Hadith

Hadith sciences rest on inductive leaps. which is simply assuming past reliability guarantees future truth. But as Hume...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

The Quranic Warning Fulfilled: Scholars as Legislative Lords

Jewish rabbis and Muslim scholars have both expanded simple scriptural commands into overly complex systems, turning specific prohibitions...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

Whitewashing al-Zuhri — and Why It Fails

Sunni tradition idealizes al-Zuhri to protect vast hadith chains dependent on him, downplaying his decades of Umayyad service....

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

The Resurrection’s 500 Witnesses? One Chain, Not 500.

The article applies isnād criticism to 1 Corinthians 15:6, showing Paul’s “500 witnesses” claim is a single-source, unverifiable...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

Al-Shāfiʿī’s Argument For Probabilistic Hadith – Refuted.

Al-Shāfiʿī argues that accepting solitary hadith is justified by analogy to Quranic cases requiring ijtihād. The article refutes...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

The Concept of “Established Practice”

The Quran assumes core worship practices like prayer and fasting were inherited traditions, not newly invented rituals. Early...

Read Aug 2025

BLOG

Exposing Flaws in Dr. Shadee Elmasry’s Hadith Defense

Dr. Shadee Elmasry distorts and misrepresents the Western epistemology of hadith by building strawman arguments, projecting colonialist motives,...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

Reflections After Reading al-Shāfiʿī’s “Kitāb Jāmiʿ al-ʿIlm”

A Quran-alone critique of Imam al-Shāfiʿī’s Kitāb Jāmiʿ al-ʿIlm, arguing the debate with a so-called Quranist was staged...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

Before Madhabs – Dirār’s Stance Against Hadith

Dirār ibn ʿAmr al-Ghaṭṭāfānī (d. ca. 845/220 AH) was a Basran judge known for “radical” rationalist views. In...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

The Traditional Distortion of 4:3 – Polygamy

The Quranic verse 4:3 establishes polygamy as a conditional social welfare mechanism for orphan care, not a general...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

Quran 22:15: Suicide or Salvation?

22:15 has been mistranslated and misunderstood for centuries, with scholars wrongly interpreting it as commanding suicide. This contradicts...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

The Myth of the ‘Ten Promised Paradise’ Hadith

This analysis argues the hadith listing ten companions guaranteed Paradise is a constructed tradition. Primarily traced to Saʿid...

Read Jul 2025

BLOG

“The Companions All Agreed!” – No, They Didn’t.

The companions of the Prophet disagreed on core issues like temporary marriage, proving that “consensus” was a later...

Read Jun 2025

BLOG

The Fraud of Bukhari’s ‘Fourth Criterion’

Bukhari’s famed “proven meeting” criterion is often seen as a hallmark of hadith authenticity. Yet it relies on...

Read Jun 2025

BLOG

Quran-Centrism Does NOT Work

Quran-centrism creates an impossible theological choice: either falsely attribute unverified statements to the Prophet Muhammad (a serious religious...

Read Jun 2025

BLOG

Bukhari’s Blind Spot: The Problem of Aisha’s Pre-Birth Narrations

This analysis examines how Bukhari accepted Aisha's detailed narration of Prophet Muhammad's first revelation despite her not being...

Read Jun 2025

BLOG

Ibn Taymiyah’s Views on Arab Superiority

Ibn Taymiyah's claims of inherent Arab racial superiority directly contradict the Quran's clear emphasis on equality based on...

Read Apr 2025

BLOG

False Verses Added Into The Mushaf – An Umayyad Exposé

The article argues that verses 9:128-129 were added to the Quran during Uthman's compilation based on weak testimony,...

Read Apr 2025

BLOG

Hadith Logically Can Not Be Considered ‘Wahi’.

Hadith cannot be classified as "wahi" (divine revelation) because they are not verbatim accounts of the Prophet's words....

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

A Case Study of Ibn Abbas & Ikrima in The Muwatta

Imam Malik critically viewed Ikrima as an unreliable hadith narrator, citing theological deviance and questionable scholarly integrity, despite...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Al-A’mash Did Not Want You To Beat Yourself For Husayn

We explore how Al-A'mash fabricated an anti-mourning hadith to delegitimize Shi'a practices after Karbala. Analysis of transmission chains...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

The Origin of Islamic Apostasy: The Slave of Ibn Abbas

‘Ikrimah’s Kharijite leanings influenced his transmission of hadiths advocating immediate execution for apostates, shaping later Islamic jurisprudence. Imam...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Flogging, Torture, and Transmission of Hadith

Hadith compilations were shaped (in-part) by political power, with rulers enforcing "official" teachings and punishing dissenting scholars. This...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Hudhayfah ibn al-Yaman & The False Story of ‘The Keeper of Secrets’

This blog critically examines hadith narrations about the Prophet identifying hypocrites, analyzing their transmission chains and historical reliability....

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Ṣaḥīḥ al-Yahūd – Being Merciful To Inhabitants of Earth

The hadith—"The merciful are shown mercy by the Most Merciful..."—closely mirrors Shabbat 151b:14 in the Talmud. Given 7th/8th-century...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Isnad Politics: The Case of Al-A’mash and Hisham

This blog reveals how we uncovered Al-A'mash's deliberate practice of taking hadith directly from Hisham ibn Urwa while...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Abu Hurairah Lost The Zakat To a Jinn

The hadith appears to be a fabricated narrative designed to encourage Ayat al-Kursi recitation, leveraging a supernatural encounter...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Hisham ibn Urwa: The Man Who Stopped Menstruating Women From Praying

There's a legal ruling provided by many Islamic Ulema, that women are prohibited from praying during menstruation. The...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Ṣaḥīḥ al-Yahūd – The Parable of The Believer & The Citron

Jewish fruit allegory traveled from Talmudic sources through Ibn Mas'ud's companion, before Qatada elevated it to prophetic status,...

Read Mar 2025

BLOG

Fallible Transmitters Transmitting Infallible Text (The Quran)

Evidence shows that the so-called canonical Quran transmitter, Abū ʿAmr, deliberately altered the divine Quranic recitation to "correct"...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Points & Refutations Against: “Beware of This Islamic Creator”

FAZ attempts to refute a muslim convert that came out and rejected hadith. He utterly fails to provide...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: The Conquest of Constantinople

A famous Islamic hadith prophecy about conquering Constantinople, long attributed to Mehmed II's 1453 victory, originated as motivational...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

The Prophet Did Not Know The Future

This refutation highlights that Muhammad, while chosen as a messenger of God, was not granted knowledge of the...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: THE THIRTY-YEAR REIGN

The alleged prophecy of a thirty-year caliphate followed by monarchy emerges from a hadith whose sole transmitter, Sa'id...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: “HOLD ON TO THESE 6 THINGS THAT WILL OCCUR IN THE FUTURE”

Awf ibn Malik likely fabricated the hadith, using his firsthand experiences, long life, and esteemed status to retroactively...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

The Double Life of ʿAbbād ibn Yaʿqūb – The Sunni 12er

ʿAbbād ibn Yaʿqūb led a double life, appearing as a trustworthy Sunni narrator while secretly holding and transmitting...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Imām Abū Hanīfa – False Attributions

The emergence of Abu Hanifa musnads and other collections primarily in the fourth/tenth century, well over a century...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: THE PROPHESIED RETURN OF DHUL-KHALASA

This fabricated hadith claims that the idol of Daus would reemerge near the end of times. However, we...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: THE KILLING OF ‘UMAR & THE AFFLICTIONS

Apologists claim that the hadith represents divine revelation due to the prophetic nature of certain narratives within the...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: RETURN TO GREEN ARABIA

A fabricated hadith prophecy about Arabia turning back to a land of meadows and rivers. This is part...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Shia’s Transmitting Hadith In Sahih Al-Bukhari ?!

Self-Proclaimed Sunni Historian on X challenges anyone: 'Show me one Rafidi Shia in the chains of al-Bukhari!' Well...

Read Feb 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: The Siege of Baghdad

Apologists claim the hadith corpus contains prophecies proving its divine nature. Examining the hadith of 'The Siege of...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: The Fire From Hijaz & The Eruption of 641 AD

Apologists claim the hadith corpus contains prophecies proving its divine nature. Examining the hadith of the Hijazi fire...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

Battle of The Isnads: Judaism vs. Christianity vs. Islam

Judaism, Christianity, and Islam all maintain chains of transmission to preserve teachings; Islam isn't unique. However, Judaism and...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

The Abbasid Mahdi – The Black Banners & Abu Abbas Al-Saffah

The black banner hadith, initially used by the Abbasids as propaganda to legitimize their uprising against the Umayyads,...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

Hadith: The Prophet Was Bewitched By A Jew … ?

Hisham ibn Urwah fabricated the bewitching hadith in Medina to defend the Prophet’s divine protection, later altering it...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

Exposing the False Use of ‘Ummiyeen’ in Hadith

This post analyzes the incorrect use of "Ummiyeen" in hadith, showing how fabricators like Asim misinterpreted the term...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

Hadith Scholars Fulfilling Their Desires in Hadith

The history of hadith transmission includes instances of narrators manipulating texts to enforce practices not commanded by the...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

ʿIlm al-Rijāl (علم الرجال) – A Case Study Of This Flawed Science

ʿIkrimah, a scholar of Quran and jurisprudence, faced mixed reviews for his character. Despite some regarding him as...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

The Corruption of Prayer Within The Hadith

This article argues that the Muwatta of Imam Malik does not provide a complete guide to prayer, emphasizing...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

The Kaysanite Mahdi – The Obscure 3rd Son of Ali

The hadiths regarding the Mahdi emphasize his lineage from Prophet Muhammad's family, asserting he will bring justice, reflecting...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

The Hasanid Mahdi – A Mahdi Fabricated by Asim (Teacher of Quran Reciter Hafs)

The hadith discusses a Mahdi expected to restore justice, linked to Muhammad ibn Abdullah. Its transmission is questionable,...

Read Jan 2025

BLOG

The Salafi Paradox

The article examines the Salafi rejection of Tawassul and Istighatha, contrasting it with Sunni scholarly consensus that endorses...

Read Dec 2024

BLOG

Imam Ahmad Supplicated Through Dead People

Prophet Muhammad's mission emphasized pure monotheism, challenging Quraysh's idol worship. Despite Quranic teachings, notable Sunni scholars endorsed intermediary...

Read Dec 2024

BLOG

The Hadith of Angels Cursing Women Who Don’t Sleep With Their Husbands

This narration has long been controversial, not only due to its ethical implications but also because of potential...

Read Nov 2024

BLOG

The Hadith of the Drought – Al-Albani Refutation

The website alalbany.org is the official page of the Imam Al-Albani Center for Studies and Research, dedicated to...

Read Nov 2024

BLOG

Muhammad Did Not Split The Moon.

The splitting of the moon (Surah Al-Qamar, 54:1) is widely regarded as a miracle performed by Prophet Muhammad....

Read Oct 2024

BLOG

The Satanic Verses Incident

The Satanic Verses in Early Islamic Narratives: An Analysis of Historical Transmission The story of the Satanic Verses...

Read Sep 2024

BLOG

Divine Inspirations: An Analytical Comparison of Caedmon’s and Muhammad’s Revelations

hether through direct influence, shared oral tradition, or common biblical inspiration, the stories of Caedmon and Muhammad’s divine...

Read Sep 2024

BLOG

How Long Did The Prophet Stay In Mecca?

How Long Did The Prophet Stay In Mecca After Receiving Prophethood? This answer should be easy to answer....

Read Apr 2024

BLOG

Angel Gabriel – 600 Wings?

Hadith states Angel Gabriel has 600 wings in exegesis of surah 53. The Quran has a different answer.

Read Apr 2024

BLOG

Fabricated Hadith Prophecy: Bedouins Building Tall Buildings

‘RAGS TO RICHES’ THE BEDOUINS PROPHECY A common trope that adherents to hadith like to cling on to,...

Read Apr 2024

BLOG

The Dajjal – An Apocryphal Creation

The Dajjal, an intriguing figure in Islamic eschatology, symbolizes deception and chaos before the Day of Judgment, paralleling...

Read May 2023

BLOG

The Zubayrid Mahdi – The Zubayrid Retaliation Against the Umayyads!

The weak narration from Sunnan Abi Dawud describes events preceding the arrival of Imam Mahdi, but it is...

Read May 2023

BLOG

The Descension of Jesus in The End of Times – Umayyad Propaganda

One of the central concepts within Islamic eschatology is the belief in the second coming of Jesus Christ,...

Read May 2023

BLOG

The Law of Apostasy – The Sneaky Khawariji in The Hadith Corpus

Apostasy executions is a belief held by Sunni Muslims, based upon hadith narrated by Ikrima. When we look...

Read May 2023